A Book Review: Hemingway’s Girl

Before my massage last Saturday, my mom showed me a list of books she wants to read.  Sidenote: It was handwritten on three sheets of lined paper because my mom is cute like that.  It was mostly classics.  You know, stuff you probably (or should’ve) read in school, like Fahrenheit 451, To Kill a Mockingbird and Animal Farm.  A lot of it was stuff I haven’t read but want to!  Classics are classics for a reason.  They’re the backbone of our literary history!

The book I just finished was so not on that list.


You know, I should probably stop assuming anything by or about Hemingway means I’m going to love it.  That assumption might work nine times out of ten, but that tenth one might turn out to be horribly boring and hard to get through because you’re thinking “Is anything interesting going to happen?!” the entire time you’re reading it.  Case in point: Hemingway’s Girl by Erika Robuck.

This one is about a girl named Mariella who works for and is also attracted to Hemingway, who happens to be married at the time.  Turns out he’s attracted to her too but there’s that whole being married part and that other part where Mariella meets and falls in love with another guy.  The whole thing takes place in Key West and can I just say I like European Hemingway way better than Key West Hemingway.

Overall, the entire book was just so… vanilla.  The story wasn’t interesting, the characters weren’t captivating, the writing wasn’t fine-tuned.  Plus there was that part where Robuck decided to have Mariella and Hemingway refer to each other as “Papa” and “Daughter” and it got majorly weird.  Oddly enough, the last few pages of the book were told in letter-format and I actually kind of liked that.  I’m a sucker for a good letter-style book.

In other words, if you come across this one, skip it.


What was the last really good book you read?

What was the last really bad book you read?

Do you have a favorite “classic”?

In other news, my mom and I just decided to create a two-person book club to take down those classics!

8 thoughts on “A Book Review: Hemingway’s Girl

  1. My favorite classic is To Kill a Mockingbird! And the book I’m currently reading is called Spring Chicken. It’s a book about the science of aging. Sounds boring but it’s a fascinating read!

  2. Given your interest in reading, I would say that it would be a worthwhile investment of time. Besides being able to see what your friends are reading or have read, you can also read a plethora of reviews from people that really love reading, sign up for free review copies of future releases, organize your want to read list and join book clubs.

  3. LOVE book posts!!! I have reached my reading goal of 75 books last month (no, I truly don’t have a life).. My favourite classic is hands down Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen, I love her wit, and feminism in the 1800s. A more modern classic which I love is The Great Gastby.

    • Wow!!! That’s a lot of books! I’m impressed. I re-read The Great Gatsby a few years ago when the movie came out and I… didn’t like it. Don’t hate me 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s